North Kohala Community Development Plan Advisory Group
Meeting of _Sept 7, 2026______Old Courthouse.
Minutes by _____annalene _______
Call to order at __4:31pm______
Approx ___4____ in attendance from the community. _____7______ In attendance from AG committee:
Annalene Kotzé, John Winter, Sadie Young, Kathy Matsuda, Boyd Bond, Jack Hoyt, Karl Toubman
____Aug_____Meeting minutes approved –
SubGroup meeting reports:
Affordable Housing (Homes For Kohala)
Kohala Community Land Trust: KCLT will host four free educational workshops on Saturdays from 10-12 in September and October at the Senior Center. The workshops include: buyer readiness, property tax & home insurance, title issues & estate planning, and ‘ohana decision-making.
Help for distressed homeowners: KCLT seeks to gather information at the workshops on how best to assist homeowners in need with property taxes, liens, and repairs. One model would be to provide funding in return for future affordability deed restrictions so a portion of the housing stock is permanently protected to help keep our community here.
- Workshop series was developed based on the model used by Kīpuka Kuleana on Kauaʻi’s North Shore, successfully run since 2016.
- KCLT requested $30,000 (for 8 workshops) from an Atherton grant; $15,000 was awarded, funding 4 workshops. An additional $20,000 in unrestricted KCLT funds is also being applied.
- Workshop 1 (buyer readiness): includes updates from Hawaiʻi Island Community Development Corporation (HICDC) on the next phase of self-help housing, and information on County Office of Housing and Community Development renter/buyer programs, including how Section 8 tenants’ rent increases are escrowed into an interest-bearing down-payment account.
- KCLT is partnering with Hawaiian Community Assets (a HUD-certified CDFI) to pre-certify prospective buyers for lenders.
- Workshop 2 (property tax & home insurance) is scheduled for September 19. Presenters: Lisa Mayoro (County property tax division) and Tad Nottage (Aloha Insurance Services). Noted: A new state law allows the lowest possible tax rate for properties held in the same family for over 100 years.
- Workshop 3 (title issues & estate planning), originally planned for October 10, has been moved to October 24 due to a presenter conflict. Presenters: Shana Kahiapo (Aloha Legacy Law, specializing in Native Hawaiian trust/estate work) and, likely, Sheikha Makaala (title research, previously worked with HILT on the Mahukona process).
- Workshop 4 (‘ohana decision-making) will offer two approaches: Auntie Lahela Cruz (Hoʻoponopono practitioner and Hoʻokohai teacher) and West Hawaii Mediation Center (conflict resolution).
- KCLT is also developing a program to place affordability deed restrictions on existing homes in exchange for funding help with repairs, insurance, or title clearing — modeled in part on Lahaina’s insurance-gap program.
- Individual flyers will be produced and posted for each workshop; a full report/article on the series is planned for the October community paper.
- Reminder: self-help homes built by HICDC carried only a 10-year deed restriction, so those units have since reverted to market pricing and are no longer part of the affordable housing pool — underscoring why KCLT’s permanent deed-restriction model matters.
Kumakua Self-help Phase 3 project work is stalled for now
Hawi Nani project is also on pause since they are unable to obtain water meters.
Homes for Kohala is also having ongoing conversations about using public land as a long-term asset to support the community’s vision.
The next meeting will be September 9th, 9 am at the Kohala Public Library.
Agriculture
Did not meet in August.
Next meeting September 24th, 5 pm at the Resource Center office.
Community Access (see maps on last page for locations)
Pololu Lookout
Na Ala Hele postponed Pololu trail restoration. Bidders too expensive or not qualified
Mule Station transfer moving along.
Start & go: the State was going to hire someone to do a study on the trail; didn’t get any bids
Trails condition, best practices, longevity & climate resilience
Hapu’u – Kapanaia
David Fuertes asked Kohala Lihikai to consider doing maintenance on PONC parcel adjacent to/accessible through his property
Toni plans to meet with the County to work out how to do a combined proposal for all the PONC parcels along the corridor
Upolu Point – Mayor reviewing and prioritizing all parcels with outstanding Council resolutions.
Mahukona – Hui Mamalahoa meeting concurrently with this meeting to discuss their access through HILT property
Kohala Coastal Network – Next meeting on September 28th at 11:00 on zoom.
Lamaloloa
Archeological inventory survey has been started on upper portion
Outreach with Culture and History Hui in August to engage community as with lower portion.
Took students out to participate and interest them in archeology careers
PONC – Bill 165 that would have increased maintenance fund failed to pass
Ben Schapiro left so they are again without an administrator.
- PONC parcels: staffing gaps (previously vacant, now filled by a new administrator) had slowed work; a community convening (~50 past stakeholders) recently reviewed possible charter/ordinance amendments. A stewardship-focused amendment was largely stripped out during that process, leaving only a modest increase to maintenance funding.
- PONC ranking process clarified: PONC commissioners rank parcels annually by conservation significance regardless of whether an owner is currently willing to sell; Kohala’s history of resubmitting parcels each year (e.g., Mahukona) kept them near the top of the list once a willing seller emerged. The Mayor’s recent deprioritization of some North Kohala parcels reflects reallocation toward other districts with new urgency (e.g., the Olsen Trust parcel), not a blanket deprioritization of Kohala.
- Presented matching funds for agricultural conservation easement for lo’i patch,
Conservation entities, mutually self-supportive
Next meeting October 7th, 4:30pm Senior Center.
Culture & History Advisory Group (KCHAG).
Have had requests from others to use Front Porch set for Kohala Reunion, but need to have liability waiver for others to use.
Would like to find lineal descendants in various ahupua’a for meetings.
Any update on work to restart Civic Club?
- Hawaiian Civic Club update: the club has been dormant since its would-be leader, Keke, passed away suddenly last year shortly before she was to hold her first organizing meeting. Her intended successor has since relocated to South Kona. KCHAG plans to reach out to statewide civic club chapters for help finding a new local leader, while being mindful it is not KCHAG’s kuleana to run the club itself.
Return Mahukona Stone to proper placement?
Ho’ola project at Upolu Point?
Reported on NKCDP-AG and Subcommittee issues.
Aric Arakaki (Ala Kahakai): – Role is as NGO supporting non-profit mission. Will contact Akoni Nelson for possible huaka’i. Doing archaeological survey at Lamalaloa (south of Lapakahi), want to have community involved in work; contact Aric if interested. Will set up KCHAG huaka’i to Lamalaloa for October. Have had students out to Mahukona to teach them how to find trails. Provided funding to Kohala Lihikai, hired La Crivello on project for GIS database & story maps.
Next meeting will be September 14th 10 am at Walker Hall (St. Augustine)
Growth Management
Pololu Lookout plan; port-a potties, design and planning approved. No new action on the valley rim subdivision, the road is considered a repair, so no need for a permit.
Hawi Nani subdivision. The current planning consultant Mark Fox, for Mark Lester reported to Affordable Housing that “water meters appear impossible”.
- Clarification from Jack Hoyt: Mark Lester’s proposal designates 51% of the subdivision as affordable housing lots, with the remaining 49% as market-rate lots. The Department of Water Supply has agreed to provide water for the affordable lots, but the market-rate lots will require a separate well. Mark Fox assisted Mark Lester in subdividing the roughly 200-acre parcel — which extends from the ocean up to Hoea — into six lots. Lester’s existing well serves five of those lots; the remaining 33-acre lot was not connected to that well and currently has no water access other than through the Department of Water Supply. The Department has indicated the developer will need to dig an additional well for that lot, as County water meters will only be issued for the affordable-designated lot
Momematorim to be dropped when Halaula Well is certified? – not sure if that will happen
Old Coast Guard Road transfer still in a tangle. Toni continues to apply pressure on Tim Richards. Rascha wrote an appeal to him advocating for the State to repair the road so the County can manage it.
Upolu Point, 88 acres. The Mayor is not open to negotiations using the PONC funds. “Kohala has more than its share.” Toni will continue to chase this and report that the owner is willing to take a discount. The County Council has called on the administration to proceed.
General Plan passed by County Council June 26 – some amendments not yet seen.
Agricultural easements. Key points
- Feds will pay landowners a onetime price for keeping land (or a portion of a parcel) in agriculture or conservation in perpetuity.
- In order to apply, easement has to be held by a non-profit
- HILT and Moku o Keawe are two NP able to apply
- PONC can be used to purchase easements
- The easement goes with the land
- This process is vulnerable to abuse
- Open question raised (unresolved): why isn’t KCLT listed as an entity eligible to hold agricultural conservation easements, alongside HILT and Moku o Keawe
Next meeting is September 9th, 5pm, Senior Center.
Health and Wellness/WRK
Did not meet in August, however…
St. Aug. lreceived a grant so Kohala Food hub prepares a fresh produce bag. St. Augustine’s Food Pantry (former Kohala Cares) still have their regular canned goods bag so people have an option for 1 bag or 2.
Aloha kākou! In the wake of Lala the outpouring of civic engagement and community aloha has been incredible: distributing meals, cutting down trees, driving long distances to help another community, and spending hours sorting donations. People have been showing up in every way.
KōCreate: Civic Grants now open, funding meant for exactly this kind of kōkua! Awards of up to $1,000. The application is short and takes just a few minutes. Apply today: bit.ly/vh-civicgrant
The Kohala Resilience Hub wishes to host a community meeting after Hurricane Lala.
Dinner by Chaba. Have people sit at tables and each table with someone to facilitate. We have questions prepared. We come together. Second meeting would bring in other organizations like HELCO, Dept. of Water Supply, County and present info from our first meeting.
Next meeting September 18th, 4:00pm. Senior Center.
Parks, Roads, Erosion Control and View-planes (PREV)
The state plans to repave Akoni Pule Highway from Kawaihae to Hawi. Not sure when.
- a FLIR (forward-looking infrared) traffic camera has been installed on a pole in Hāwī monitoring Akoni Pule Highway. Likely State/HDOT-related, possibly tied to highway repaving and traffic-flow tracking; a second camera on Hāwī Hill Road is unconfirmed.
Mahukona Beach Park Group will meet with Parks and Recreation senior staff and our elected representatives regarding the stalled progress in replacing the pavilion. Probably Sept 18 in Hilo.
- County Parks & Rec declined to hold a meeting in Kohala; a small group will instead travel to meet with Parks & Rec staff in Hilo, tentatively Sept 18 at 2:00 pm (unconfirmed as of the meeting; County had not returned calls).
Next meeting is September 16th, 5:00pm Senior Center.
Utilities
Hurricane Lala discussion. Centered on the outage maps and how they could be improved to provide more specificity as to time and date of restoration. In addition, it would be helpful to have a map showing the main transmission lines and other crucial components of the grid. A letter will be drafted to provide feedback to HECO on the maps and other issues related to the storm related power failures and restoration. The effects of the outage helped to spotlight our dependency on the grid, its vulnerability, and the importance of conserving power usage and for resident having some sort of back-up power supply. Suggestion for better tree trimming.
- Idea raised for a future meeting topic: bringing in a speaker on off-grid living options for individuals, including a cost-ranked list of backup power options (batteries, solar, generators).
- Idea raised for a dedicated Kohala outage-reporting contact/system (e.g., a call-in number) so residents without power can be tracked and connected to help, separate from HELCO’s own outage map.
Greenwaste Update– Years ago the County managed to sign a contract with Hawaiian Earth Recycling, who operates the West Hawaii landfill at Pu’uanahulu. There are tonnage requirements in that contract and if the County doesn’t meet them, they pay penalties. Now that they are trucking East Hawaii waste to the West Hawaii landfill, they may more readily satisfy the minimum requirements. These minima, if not met, would certainly affect the County’s participation in diverting Kohala greenwaste to our proposed local greenwaste facility. John Winter has volunteered to try to gain more specifics on the terms of the contract and if greenwaste could be diverted without triggering a penalty.
How long contract in place: forever (perpetuity)
Water Utility Update-The power outage affected the ability of the pumps to send water to the reservoirs. Notices from the Department of Water Supply were sent in advance of the storm encouraging water conservation and essential use. We should encourage DWS to have back-up generators at all North Kohala wells.
Have purchased more generators; still can’t afford to furnish all the pumps
Do we have replacement parts now? Don’t think we do; not all pumps are the same
Next meeting is September 16th, 3:30pm Senior Center.
NEW BUSINESS:
ANNOUNCEMENTS:
- Kohala Resilience Fair – postponed due to Hurricane Lala. New time TBD..
- Office of Sustainability, Climate, Equity, and Resilience (OSCER) and Hawaii Public Health are sponsoring a county-wide workshop to focus on the climate crisis and heat resilience. September 17th. 4:30- 7:00 pm, Kohala Intergenerational Center.
- Kupuna Day – 10am – 1pm, Kohala Village Barn, Chaba catering. Sept 12th. Have to register; contact Kathy
Report From Our Council Representative, James Hustace.
Committee — September 15
- Bill 147; consideration of proposed updates to transient accommodation enforcement
- Bill 183; review of proposed sewer rate increases and a new hotel service class
- Bills 186 and 187; consideration of the Waikōloa Green housing proposal, including conditions addressing wildfire resilience and mauka drainage and flood mitigation
Council — September 16
- Bill 169; improvements to PONC acquisition timelines and reassessment requirements
- Bill 176; establishes General Plan review process and timelines
- Bill 184; native plant requirements in County landscaping
PUBLIC INPUT AND AGENDA SUGGESTIONS FOR THE NEXT MEETING
Adjourned at. ___5:44____
Next meeting: on Monday,___Oct 5th______, 4:30pm, Senior Center.

